Park Avenue Homeowner Must Relocate Shed from Town Land Following Addition Approval

Key Points

  • Commission requires 11 Park Avenue homeowner to remove a shed currently encroaching on town-owned conservation land
  • New retractable aluminum ramp system approved at 248 Central Avenue to prevent recurring storm damage to coastal stairs
  • 20 Ridge Hill Road reconstruction to include native grass restoration as an alternative to traditional turf lawn
  • Commission continues marina pile replacement and residential deck projects pending more detailed construction methods and site plans
  • Members honor the legacy of longtime trail leader Howard Matthews following his passing at age 89

Protecting town-owned conservation land emerged as a primary focus for the Scituate Conservation Commission during its Wednesday evening session, as members addressed a series of residential projects ranging from storm-resistant ramps to native grass restoration. The meeting began with a sharp eye on property boundaries at 11 Park Avenue, where Joe Webbby of Webbby Surveying presented a proposal for a small addition on helical piles designed to limit ground disturbance. While the Commission found the addition acceptable, Chair Frank Snow identified a significant encroachment on the project site. I have a question about the shed. It appears to be on land owned by the Scituate Conservation Commission, Snow noted. Webbby indicated the homeowner would likely be willing to move the structure, which sits on blocks. Conservation Agent Jennifer Bachman suggested a formal requirement to rectify the issue. Motion Made by P. Scott-Pipe to issue the Order of Conditions with the condition that the shed must be moved off conservation property. Motion Passed (6-0).

The Commission also reviewed a creative solution for coastal storm resilience at 248 Central Avenue. Dennis Donovan presented a plan to replace stairs destroyed in a recent storm with a 30-foot retractable aluminum ramp and landing system. The aluminum gangway will drop down instead of me chasing wooden stairs across Central Avenue after a storm, Donovan explained, noting the system allows the stairs to be lifted out of harm's way during high-velocity weather events. Motion Made by P. Scott-Pipe to issue a Negative 2 Determination. Motion Passed (6-0).

At 20 Ridge Hill Road, the discussion turned toward ecological restoration during a continued hearing for a single-family home reconstruction. Brad Holmes of ECR detailed a mitigation plan involving 2,900 square feet of restoration to improve the wetland buffer. Member Eric pushed the applicant further, suggesting that remaining lawn areas be converted from traditional turf to native species like Bouteloua gracilis to provide ecological function while remaining usable as a yard. Applicant Emma Lawson expressed her support for the initiative, stating, I definitely want to preserve the environment. If that's something that has to happen, I'm on board as long as I can still use the space. Holmes agreed to work with the Commission on the specific seed mix for the final conditions. Motion Made by P. Scott-Pipe to close the hearing. Motion Passed (6-0).

The meeting also addressed navigational and maintenance issues along the river. Rick Savant presented a float relocation project at 232 Central Avenue intended to ease congestion between neighboring docks. Member Roger raised concerns about the construction process, noting that the work would be conducted from a barge. I agree. Let's be cautious and avoid the issues we've seen in the past, Roger said regarding potential accidents in the channel. Eric requested a condition that work be restricted to high tide periods to prevent the barge from grounding. Motion Made by P. Scott-Pipe to issue the Order of Conditions. Motion Passed (6-0). Similarly, at 60 New Driftway, a request to replace ice-damaged piles at a marina was continued after Snow expressed concern about the sediment impact of certain installation methods. I want to be sure they aren't 'jetting' or pumping water to move mud, which stirs up sediment, Snow said, requesting a detailed means and methods statement from the contractor.

A more complex request for a cantilever deck at 25 Julian Street faced delays due to missing details on the submitted site plans. Members Robbie and Eric noted that the current drawings failed to clearly show the location of new piles and stairs. It's hard to understand what's going on, Robbie remarked. Representative Paul Ladderback acknowledged the need for clarity, stating, I will coordinate with Jen and resubmit a plan that is easier to understand, showing the new piles and the stairs. The matter was continued to a future meeting. Earlier in the session, acting Chair Brendan Collins presided over the finalization of orders for 164 Turner Road while Snow remained recused. We have the first order of business, the Order of Conditions for 164, Collins said before the board moved to finalize the coastal dune project. Motion Made by P. Scott-Pipe to accept the orders as written. Motion Passed (5-0).

The evening concluded with a somber tribute to Howard Matthews, the town's longtime trail volunteer and leader who recently passed away just shy of his 90th birthday. Snow praised Matthews as super dedicated to the trail system and noted he was still flagging properties for the town as recently as last month. I go back with Howard over 25 years. He and my late husband were very close friends, Penny Scott-Pipe shared. I can't say enough about him. He will be missed. The Commission is currently exploring the possibility of naming a trail or creating a formal dedication in his honor.