Potential Property Tax Overrides Loom as Inflation Drives 40 Percent Paving Cost Spikes
Key Points
- Select Board Chair Andrew Goodrich warned that a tax override may be necessary next year to combat 40 percent increases in paving costs and inflation.
- The $27 million North Scituate sewer project is slated for a spring construction start, funded by a mix of grants and property owner betterments.
- Town officials recommended demolishing the old Pier 44 Community Center to create a $3.8 million waterfront park, pending a Fall Town Meeting vote.
- A redesigned Harbor Gazebo is currently out to bid and is expected to return for the 2027 summer season.
- The Economic Development Commission is launching a data-driven social media marketing pilot this spring to boost local tourism and business attraction.
Scituate residents and business leaders gathered at the Community Center on May 14 for the annual State of the Town panel, where officials delivered a sobering forecast of rising infrastructure costs and the increasing likelihood of a future tax override. While the town has successfully navigated recent fiscal years without exceeding the limits of Proposition 2 ½, Select Board Chair Andrew Goodrich cautioned that the era of avoidance may be nearing its end due to unprecedented inflationary pressures.
Goodrich highlighted the drastic impact of rising material costs on local maintenance, specifically pointing to the petroleum-dependent price of roadwork. Asphalt is 40% more expensive because it's made from petroleum, which means 40% of the streets we wanted to pave won't get done,
Goodrich explained. He noted that while the town is pushing for federal and state advocacy to fix long delays in seawall funding, local aid has failed to keep pace with inflation. The priority is really the budget. We were able to get through this past year without an override, but next year, I don't know if that's going to be the case. I don't want anyone to have that surprise.
The financial conversation extended to the massive $27 million North Scituate sewer project, which Town Administrator James Boudreau described as a catalyst for local revitalization. The project has secured a $5 million MassWorks grant and is awaiting word on an additional $15 million in federal funding requests. Despite these grants, a significant portion of the cost will be funded through betterments—special assessments levied against the property owners who benefit from the new infrastructure. Boudreau noted that the town will hold a public meeting mid-summer to detail these costs for residents.
The grant doesn't impact the timeline; it just takes back the cost,
Boudreau said. He emphasized that the project is expected to go to bid in early autumn with construction starting next spring. Our MassWorks grant estimates that putting in the sewer could open up over 200,000 square feet of retail space and over 400 units of housing. North Scituate is a gem waiting to be uncovered.
Infrastructure updates also touched on the fate of the old Pier 44 property, a project that has transitioned into its final design and funding phase. Boudreau recommended the demolition of the old Community Center building to make way for a $3.8 million park project, which includes $1 million dedicated to front revetment repairs. The administrator explained that federal flood regulations would make renovating the current structure nearly impossible, as any major touch would require elevating the building 16 feet into the air. This proposal is slated for a vote at the Fall Town Meeting. Regarding the iconic harbor gazebo, which was recently removed, Boudreau assured the audience that a slightly larger version is currently out to bid. I made the mistake of going on social media about the conspiracy that we were tearing it down,
Boudreau joked. You can have the engineering reports—it was falling down. It'll be back next summer and I think people are really going to like it.
Barry Kurland, Chair of the Economic Development Commission (EDC), outlined a strategic shift for the town’s business support, moving away from anecdotal feedback toward data-driven marketing. The EDC is launching a pilot marketing project this spring, utilizing social media to raise Scituate's profile and tourism appeal. We want to move from anecdote to data,
Kurland said, noting the commission’s efforts to leverage state funding for place identity studies. Collaborate. Culture and business go together in Scituate. Understanding these different subcultures and being able to collaborate between them creates amazing opportunities.
The panel discussion was moderated by Chamber of Commerce Board Member Shelley Swanson, who announced the return of the 57th annual Heritage Days Festival for August 7 through 9. Chamber President Christina Carreri opened the event by acknowledging the town’s collective efforts, stating, We are grateful to everyone that continues to show up for Scituate, a town that I love so much: our residents, our businesses, and for the future of our town.
Public comment brought a plea for civic engagement from Planning Board member Ann Bourbine, who addressed the town’s aging volunteer base. We desperately need younger people on boards,
Bourbine said. The Advisory Board is the opportunity to learn everything that is going on in this town because it all comes to them. Please get involved.
Resident Lisa Berollola echoed the need for better communication, suggesting the town circle back
on surveys so residents feel their input on issues like bike paths and green spaces leads to tangible action.
In response to questions about future land use, Boudreau confirmed that the current water treatment plant will likely be razed for Little League fields once the new plant is operational. Additionally, the old Gates school campus is moving forward with the Grantham Group’s 63-unit senior housing project, which will replicate the original building’s footprint. The meeting also featured a brief introduction from School Committee candidate Erica McMahon, who is running in the upcoming June 6 election. I believe our schools deserve leadership that's thoughtful, steady, collaborative, and future-oriented,
McMahon told the audience. Strong organizations don't happen by accident. They're built with intention through trust and transparency.