The Scituate Waterways Commission focused its attention on a critical draft memorandum to the Select Board regarding the Harbor Master feasibility study, with members expressing deep reservations over the project's projected costs. Rick Murray stated that at this point in time without a realistic and complete total project cost, we do not believe it can afford to proceed with the project at this level of expense, arguing that a single-building solution is more appropriate than the proposed three-building design. Brian Kelly warned the commission of the staggering financial implications, noting the numbers for one to three could be 7 to 14 million when looking at a high-end build projected for 2029. Chairperson Dave Denine emphasized the importance of delivering a clear message before the Select Board meets with architects, remarking that we really want it to be right. Member Nick requested the final document tie that back to what dollar amount of cost of the facility to clearly show how the project impacts mooring rates, while resident Laura Solai sought clarification on the process, asking what exactly is that vote on?

Harbor Master Stephen Mone delivered a sobering report on the aftermath of Hurricane Erin, telling the community I really wouldn't advise going in the water after hurricane... it’s big waves. Mone also updated the board on the long-stalled harbor dredging permit, explaining that the town is still waiting for a suitability determination from the Army Corps of Engineers regarding the disposal of spoils. Select Board member Susan Harrison joined the meeting remotely to confirm the value of the commission’s input, noting it is a typical procedure when a study is complete that it then goes to the select board for discussion and or decision. Guest Colleen Burgess, who submitted a letter of suggestions to the board, introduced herself for the record as Colleen Burgess, 130 Oceanside Drive.

Financial discussions highlighted potential revenue gaps as the town balances dredging needs with other capital expenses. Phyllis Carl asked if the town was still playing off the fire boat and how much is that, prompting Dave Sincy to clarify that I want to say that was a 20 year note on that, with roughly five years of payments remaining. Resident Mike O'Neal questioned the underlying data used in the project models, asking did you factor in any engineering studies into the high number? In a turn to operational grievances, Howie criticized the town's maintenance of the Maritime Center parking lot, describing current temporary repairs as lipstick on a pig and insisting the deplorable conditions must be addressed permanently through collaboration with the Conservation Commission.

The meeting concluded with updates on harbor activities and the annual reorganization of board leadership. Shellfish Constable Mike reported a positive season for local waters, sharing that water samples in the rivers and harbor are actually doing really well ahead of a scheduled oyster broadcast. Member TJ advocated for maintaining a focus on the small boat experience, and Brian Cronin reported that the new kayak racks have seen great success with nearly all slots filled. Mike Gibbons provided a brief liaison update, stating there was nothing really for the board to review from the most recent economic development discussions. Following these reports, the board held its annual elections.

Motion Made by Howie to accept the agenda. Motion Passed 7-0

Motion Made by Stephen Mone for Dave Denine to continue as chair. Motion Passed 7-0

The meeting was adjourned at 6:58 PM.